Preschool in Chicago: Why I'm Saying "Forget it"

Silly_girls
Written by: Dani Brzozowski

Dani Brzozowski is a mom, runner, and blogger (Hello Hyde Park!). After a decade of nonprofit management/fundraising, Dani is dedicating her full attention to her daughter, with occasional entrepreneurial, civic, and recreational diversions. Though the words "entrepreneurial, civic, and recreational" don't sound like fun, Dani prides herself on not taking any of this (or life in general) too seriously. Find her on Twitter @hellohydepark or, more frequently, on the playroom floor, building block towers or teaching S to dance.

I’ve just missed the first round of preschool open houses in Hyde Park. I have a daughter, S, whose peers have all been introduced around: to preschool teachers, administrators, and their soon-to-be-classmates. In Hyde Park, where kids start school as early as 2, this is the plight of a 9-month-old. They can’t talk, most don’t walk. In fact, the majority of these babies (BABIES!) are still pretty drooly, crawling about, floppily waving bye-bye when no one’s leaving the room. But in a little over a year, they’ll be heading off to school, with visions of Harvard or the University of Chicago in their parents’ heads.

But I missed the first round of open houses, and I’ll miss the next round, too. Because I’m not planning on sending S to preschool. That’s right. At all. (She’s also not learning a second language. I haven’t given her a toy violin.  And the closest she’s come to playing a kiddie sport is rolling a sticky orange ball across the playroom floor.)

Maybe you’re thinking this isn’t a big deal. But in Hyde Park, where the University of Chicago reigns supreme, this decision isn’t controversial; it’s appalling.

You may have seen recent articles about “redshirting” kindergarteners. But read closely: this practice, in so many cases, is only a strategy to give children a leg up, an opportunity to be more competitive. To what end? I’m not talking about redshirting S, I’m talking about leaving her be, sending her to school when she’s good and ready, as determined by me, her mom.

The fact of the matter is that even kindergarten isn’t required in Illinois. And though I’m not saying we’ll skip kindergarten, too, we may. You’re probably thinking about the consequences: the less-prestigious grade schools, the state colleges in my kid’s future. Maybe you’re worried. I’m not. 

Here’s my thought: we put way too much pressure on kids (I’m loathe to add the phrase “these days” lest it age me inaccurately). Yes, we need to remain competitive in a global marketplace and all that, and China is outpacing us, etc, etc, etc. But it’s not our children’s responsibility to keep an eye on the GDP, and I’m not designing my daughter’s life as a strategy for addressing America’s economic concerns. As long as she’s smart enough (not educated enough, but smart enough) to find a life path that makes her happy, I’ll be satisfied that I’ve done my job as her parent.

Right now, what makes her happy is this: lots of naps; morning snuggles; frequent nursing; being chased; open-mouth kissing smaller babies; sweet potatoes; and dancing. I know these things will change, and they’ll change fast. I also know that I won’t succumb to the pressure to get her “up to speed” academically or socially. She’s up to her own speed and it’s the perfect pace for me to keep up.

Learn more about Dani by visiting her blog - Hello Hyde Park.

Posted on January 16, 2012 at 4:34 PM

Comments


8 Replies

  • Not doing the usual private preschool thing

    Loved your article, can't agree more. Because I work part time our son has been in high quality day care (which includes morning pre-school) at least part time since he was 2. But it's not one of those "prep" preschools and we never looked for one. Over the last few years, we've been gently advised that we "missed out" by not putting him in a "real private school" by age 3, to "guarantee a K slot", since there are "so few K slots" in the Chicago private schools. I have no regrets. We know that would not have been in his best interests. There's nothing wrong with quality day care and there's nothing wrong with staying home with mom (or dad). My gripe is when it's a search for a "school" for a toddler. 2 year olds need to play, whether at home or in a day care. In the process of looking into Kindergarten for our son (who is 5 now) we have encountered other couples trying to place their 2 and 3 year olds; they asked many more questions (than us) about the "curriculum" (for their smaller children). Most probably think we are nuts because we just want our child to be in a safe place where he will like the teacher and finish his lunch. We just aren't yet worried about whether his test scores will be good enough or a good high school or college. Even at age 5.

    by Mom on 01/25 at 12:12PM

    Report comment as spam / offensive

  • Amen, sistah!

    Thank you so much for writing this post, Dani. Both my husband and I work full-time (another topic that brings heated opinions, for sure), so our son is in a neighborhood daycare. But, we consider ourselves extremely fortunate to be in a daycare facility with like-minded parents. There is a laid-back, down-to-earth, let 'em be kids mentality that echos the family values we try to instill at home. I don't blame you one bit for waiting until your child is ready. That decision makes sense for your family and no one should judge you for it.

    by Nilsa @ SoMi Speaks on 01/25 at 02:02PM

    Report comment as spam / offensive

  • Thanks!

    @Mom and @Nilsa -- thanks so much for your comments! It's frustrating to feel like your position as a parent is called into question when, at day's end, you know what's best for your child and your primary goal for your children is HAPPINESS. Not "success," not getting into a good school, not being "competitive." Nice to know you're both feeling something similar and trusting your parenting instincts!

    by Dani on 01/25 at 04:47PM

    Report comment as spam / offensive

  • Devil's advocate

    OK, so I get where you're coming from. I agree with you as far as not making pre-k a competitive experience, for the kids OR parents. I'm a stay at home mom and it sounds like you are too...unlike the previous 2 posters who have their kids in daycares at least part time. I also agree that 2 is really early (and unnecessary) for any kind of organized schooling and that it won't make or break your kid's future. Here's where I completely disagree with you: I think the point of most (especially CPS) pre-k programs is about socialization. It's true they will work on letters and numbers and other topics, but won't you too? There is no testing or grading in these classes and while my eldest child is in his second year of pre-k, he has never been made to feel that learning is competitive or that it's "work". It's play-based learning that truly readies our children for not only future schooling, but for sharing and negotiating with friends, dealing with disappointment, taking direction from other authority figures and, imo, gives them a much more well-rounded experience that I could provide all on my own. The school day is only 2.5 hrs (though it may be lengthened a bit next year) so there's still plenty of time to go to museums, participate in a park-distric class, hit the parks or just play at home or with friends (some that we met AT pre-k!). Your daughter is so young, it probably does feel way to soon, and I agree that it is. But I think that forgoing pre-k altogether is kind of sad. You might feel differently in a few years because I know that sending our child to pre-k has been a wonderfully enriching experience for him...and for the whole family!

    by mom on 01/25 at 04:54PM

    Report comment as spam / offensive

  • Before you decide you should get to know your neighborhood

    Maybe you should visit the Akiba pre-k. It is award winning and play based, no worksheets or seat work. I think you might be surprised. Let me know and I will put you in touch with the director, she shares your concerns.

    by Michelle Rotfeld on 01/25 at 06:57PM

    Report comment as spam / offensive

  • Coming from a Pre-School Drop Out

    My mother did send me to pre-school, and while it may have been good for my education and socialization, she ended up withdrawing me. The reasoning at the time: I just plain didn't want to go. I didn't enjoy it. It was a fight every time. My sister and I had the chicken pox back to back, and when I was sick, I refused to get in the car with anyone else to take me. Kindergarten was nerve-wracking (and that was only half-day!) but I adjusted well in elementary school. I think mom felt that pre-school would be good for me (why else would she send me?), but when she realized how traumatic it was for me, she just let me be ready for school when I was good and ready. And since then, I got through grade school with flying colors, graduated from college, and am pursuing a career I love. You are in charge of S - she can be socialized and educated in so many different environments other than a school setting. You go, girl.

    by Mer on 01/25 at 08:01PM

    Report comment as spam / offensive

  • too soon to know

    i'd keep your options open. you don't have to go through a crazy pre-school search, but you might find that your daughter needs more stimulus at some point. at nine months, i could not picture that my three year old would be open to a learning environment outside of our home. for the record, i applied to exactly none of the competitive places and found one we really love for her. there's a difference between buying into status and buying into what your child needs. i'd really encourage you to leave your options open and follow your child ...

    by mom on 01/26 at 10:38AM

    Report comment as spam / offensive

  • Options, etc

    Thanks to everyone for commenting. I am definitely not closing any doors -- though I'm no expert, one of the keys to successful parenting for me so far has been to, at all times, remain flexible -- but my point is more to @Devil's advocate's point. Yes, I'll be teaching S her numbers, and her letters, and taking her to play groups...where she'll learn to socialize without the supervision of a teacher. She has me and plenty of other nurturing adults in her life -- why send her to preschool? And regarding dealing with disappointment, it's a lesson I'd rather she learn (much) later. She'll get there eventually, and I'm in no rush for her to become disappointed (or, let's be real, mature or jaded or unhappy in any way). And regarding sharing, there's an article in slate:" http://www.slate.com/articles/life/family/2011/10/children_and_sharing_don_t_force_kids_to_share_.html":http://www.slate.com/articles/life/family/2011/10/children_and_sharing_don_t_force_kids_to_share_.html that has stuck in my mind for months. And hi Michelle -- yes, I know Akiba's program is play-based. But then why not just get out and play with her, take her to playgroups, and let her do her own thing...on her own?

    by Dani on 01/26 at 03:00PM

    Report comment as spam / offensive

  • Reply to this topic